Are You Diversifying Your Lead Generation?
by Casey Eberhart
Meet James. He’s been running his insurance agency for nearly 15 years, serving families, small businesses, and professionals in his community. James built his agency the traditional way: through handshakes, referrals, and sponsoring local events. His business thrived for a long time, but lately, he’s noticed something unsettling.
The leads that once poured in so reliably started to slow down. Referrals were fewer, his ad in the local paper wasn’t driving calls like it used to, and he was struggling to connect with younger clients who seemed more comfortable shopping for insurance online.
James couldn’t help but wonder, “What’s changed?”
If you’re an insurance agency owner like James, this might sound familiar. While the old-school approach to generating leads worked for years, the world has shifted. Customers now research online, compare policies with a few clicks, and expect instant access to information. The traditional ways aren’t gone, but they need a boost.
The real question is: are you diversifying your lead generation strategy?
Why Relying on One Source Is Risky
For years, James relied on his strong network and reputation in the community. But as the market changed, cracks started to show:
- Referrals slowed down: His network wasn’t growing as fast as it used to, and fewer people were making personal recommendations.
- Consumer behavior shifted: Potential clients were searching online for answers and comparing quotes from competitors before ever reaching out.
- New competitors emerged: Agencies with a strong digital presence were pulling ahead, grabbing leads that James never even saw.
It became clear that relying on one or two sources for leads was no longer sustainable. The insurance landscape was evolving, and James needed to evolve with it.
What Diversification Looks Like
Diversifying your lead generation doesn’t mean abandoning what’s worked for you. Instead, it’s about expanding your efforts to meet clients where they are. James decided to embrace a mix of traditional and modern strategies to future-proof his business. Here’s what he did:
1. Optimizing for Online Visibility with SEO
James knew his website needed to do more than just exist. He hired an expert to optimize it for search engines, targeting keywords like “affordable home insurance near me” and “business liability insurance for contractors.”
This simple change helped James’ agency rank higher in search results, attracting clients who were actively searching for coverage in his area.
2. Running Targeted Ads
Digital advertising felt intimidating at first, but James quickly saw its potential. He used Google Ads to target specific searches and Facebook Ads to connect with people in his community. By tailoring his ads to specific demographics—like young families needing life insurance or business owners looking for liability coverage—he could reach exactly the audience he wanted.
3. Educating with Content Marketing
James started sharing his expertise through blog posts and short videos. He covered topics like:
- “5 Tips for Lowering Your Car Insurance Premiums.”
- “How Small Business Owners Can Save on Insurance Without Sacrificing Coverage.”
- “Understanding the Basics of Life Insurance.”
This content wasn’t just about getting noticed online; it helped position James as a trusted expert. Clients began reaching out, mentioning his blog as the reason they chose to call him.
4. Building Strategic Partnerships
James partnered with local real estate agents, mortgage brokers, and financial planners. These professionals frequently worked with clients who needed insurance, and by referring clients to each other, everyone benefited.
These partnerships opened up a new stream of referrals that felt just as personal and reliable as the ones James had built his business on.
5. Creating a Referral Program
Rather than relying on word-of-mouth to happen naturally, James introduced a formal referral program. He rewarded existing clients with gift cards or discounts on their policies when they referred friends or family members.
This simple gesture encouraged his happy clients to spread the word more proactively, leading to a steady flow of new business.
The Benefits of Diversification
Within a year, James’ business was thriving again. He wasn’t just getting more leads—he was getting better leads. People were finding him online, connecting with his social media content, and reaching out because they trusted his expertise.
Best of all, James felt secure. No longer did he worry about what would happen if one source of leads dried up. By spreading his efforts across multiple channels, he had created a resilient system that could weather changes in the market.
How to Start Diversifying Your Leads
If you’re ready to follow in James’ footsteps, here’s how you can get started:
- Evaluate Your Current Strategy: Take a close look at where your leads are coming from. Are you overly reliant on one source?
- Pick One New Channel to Try: Choose a strategy that aligns with your audience. Maybe it’s SEO, social media, or partnerships—start with one and commit to testing it for a few months.
- Track Your Results: Pay attention to what’s working and what isn’t. Look at metrics like website traffic, lead volume, and conversions to gauge success.
- Build Gradually: Don’t overwhelm yourself by trying everything at once. Focus on mastering one strategy before moving on to the next.
Final Thoughts
Diversifying your lead generation isn’t just a smart move—it’s essential in today’s competitive market. As an insurance agency owner, you already understand the value of risk management. Now it’s time to apply that principle to your own business.
Don’t wait for the phone to stop ringing before you take action. Explore new strategies, meet your clients where they are, and build a business that’s ready to thrive no matter what comes next.
So, ask yourself: are you diversifying your lead generation? If not, now’s the time to start. Follow James’ example, and you’ll set yourself up for long-term success.
Quote about the Importance of Lead Generation for Your Business:
"Relying on a single lead source is like betting your business on one card; diversify to ensure you always have a winning hand." - Casey Eberhart
Book of the week:
The Introvert’s Edge to Networking: Work the Room. Leverage Social Media. Develop Powerful Connections (Blue Link goes to Amazon)
In The Introvert’s Edge to Networking, you’ll discover how to:
- Overcome your fear and discomfort when networking
- Turn networking into a repeatable system
- Leverage your innate introverted strengths
- Target and connect with top influencers
- Leverage the power of virtual and social networking
Over 1 Million Copies SOLD!
4.6 Stars with 7296 reviews!
Grab it on Amazon —————> https://amzn.to/3IXkVjo
Business Tool of the WEEK! (Always picked to Save You TIME and/or Make You More Money)
I love this tool!
We all need to be livestreaming and up until now we didn't have the best options!
Welcome to the NEXT generation of video live streaming and recording.
There are so many cool features and benefits I am just gonna send you right to the page to check out restream....
https://try.restream.io/d2tstl0vs1v9
**I have personally switched my platform to restream for the ease and the price! **
Places to connect:
Expand The Business Facebook Community of over 4105 Business Minded folks https://www.facebook.com/groups/expandthebusiness
Our Real Estate Investor Network USA group of over 2950 Investors from around the USA https://www.facebook.com/groups/1046413479606105
**Brand New Group** Businesses For Sale By Owner with 550+ buyers and sellers in the US. https://www.facebook.com/groups/businessesforsalebyowner
Home of my YouTube channel and where the Expand The Business Podcast will live: http://www.CaseyOnVideo.com
